background image
30
T H E P R I M E R U S P A R A D I G M
Is Australia Pro-Arbitration?
Arbitration is a means of alternative
dispute resolution where disputes are heard
and determined outside a court process
by either a single arbitrator or a number
of arbitrators. Those in favor of the use of
arbitration for commercial disputes argue
that the process is less formal and the
parties have more control, including their
ability to decide on arbitrators.
1
Some of the contended benefits of
arbitration, such as the reduced time
taken to finalize disputes and the lower
cost compared to Court proceedings,
are arguable, due to the significant cost of
experienced and specialized arbitrators.
2
Arbitration has particular value in
cross-border deals, as it does not use the
court system of either party. A total of 810
new cases were filed in the largest arbitral
institute worldwide in 2017.
3
Background
This article will focus on the approach
of Australian Courts to International
Commercial Arbitration (ICA) at two
main stages. Firstly, the recognition
of arbitration clauses in commercial
contracts by Australian Courts, and
secondly, the enforcement of arbitral
awards by Australian Courts. Arbitration
in Australia is predominantly governed by
the International Arbitration Act 1974 (Cth)
(IAA)
,
4
which implements domestically the
UNCITRAL Model Law on International
Commercial Arbitration and the United
Nations Convention on the Recognition and
Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards
(New York Convention)
.
5
Recognition of Arbitration Agreements
Courts in a particular jurisdiction may have
a dispute referred to them which is covered
by an arbitration clause, but which has
not yet been referred to arbitration. Where
the arbitration agreement is governed by
the law of a state that is a party to the New
York Convention
or one of the parties to
the agreement is domiciled or an ordinary
resident in a country that is a party to the
New York Convention, the recognition of an
arbitration agreement is governed by the
Convention.
6
In such cases, courts in jurisdictions
that are a party to the New York Convention
are required to refer parties to arbitration
at the request of one of the parties, unless
it is found that the arbitration agreement
in question is null and void, inoperative or
incapable of being performed.
7
Enforcement of Arbitral Awards
Courts may also be approached once a
dispute has already been determined
through arbitration in order to enforce the
binding arbitral award that was rendered
by the arbitrator or arbitrators. In that
instance, international arbitral awards
rendered in a New York Convention
jurisdiction are generally enforceable in
other Convention jurisdictions.
8
Commercial Arbitration in Australia
It was noted in 2009 that the Australian
legal system has been somewhat slow in
embracing ICA.
9
In particular, this delay
was said to be caused by factors such
as Australia's then political isolationism
and the previous apprehensiveness of
Australian legal practitioners to consider
comparative and international law.
10
More recent assessments have
suggested that Australia's adoption of
both "top-down" and "bottom-up" reform
has successfully transformed Australia's
approach to the "top-down" level. This has
included the 2010 and 2018 amendments
to the IAA.
11
Recognition of Arbitration
Agreements
In Australia, the relevant provision
incorporating Article 2 of the New York
Convention
is Section 7(2) of the IAA,
12
which requires an Australian Court to
stay proceedings either in whole or in
part at the request of one of the parties
when presented with an unresolved matter
Asia Pacific ­ Australia
Selwyn Black leads the Business Lawyers
Group at Carroll & O'Dea Lawyers. His practice
includes advising on a variety of issues for
businesses, including acquisitions and disposals,
joint ventures, contracts and employment
arrangements, international supply and
distributorship arrangements and associated
disputes and regulatory issues.
Special thanks to contributing author
James Pinkerton.
Carroll & O'Dea Lawyers
Level 18, St. James Centre
111 Elizabeth Street
Sydney, New South Wales 2000 Australia
+61 2 9291 7100 Phone
sblack@codea.com.au
codea.com.au
Selwyn Black